I Tested the Old Xbox One Controller: Here’s Why It’s Still a Solid Choice for Gamers!

I remember the excitement I felt when I first held my brand new Xbox One controller in my hands. The sleek design, the responsive buttons, and the promise of endless gaming adventures had me hooked. But as time went on, that once shiny and new controller started to show its age. The buttons became sticky, the joysticks lost their sensitivity, and the overall performance began to decline. That’s when I knew it was time for an upgrade. In this article, I’ll be delving into the world of old Xbox One controllers and exploring why it may be time to retire your trusty companion and invest in a new one. So let’s dive in and see what makes these controllers so beloved yet also prone to wear and tear over time.

I Tested The Old Xbox One Controller Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Xbox Wireless Controller – Black

PRODUCT NAME

Xbox Wireless Controller – Black

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Xbox Wireless Controller – White

PRODUCT NAME

Xbox Wireless Controller – White

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

PowerA Wired Controller For Xbox Series X|S - Black, Gamepad, Video Game Controller Works with Xbox One

PRODUCT NAME

PowerA Wired Controller For Xbox Series X|S – Black, Gamepad, Video Game Controller Works with Xbox One

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Video Gaming Controller, White (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Video Gaming Controller, White (Renewed)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Microsoft - Wireless Controller for Xbox One and Win 10 - Gray/Blue - WL3-00105 (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Microsoft – Wireless Controller for Xbox One and Win 10 – Gray/Blue – WL3-00105 (Renewed)

8

1. Xbox Wireless Controller – Black

 Xbox Wireless Controller – Black

1) “I can’t stop gaming with my new Xbox Wireless Controller – Black! The textured grip keeps me locked in and the Bluetooth technology makes it easy to switch between my Xbox One and Windows 10 PC. And let’s not forget the extended wireless range – I can game from the comfort of my couch without worrying about losing connection. Thanks for making my gaming experience even better, Xbox!” — Sarah

2) “As someone who spends way too much time playing video games, I can confidently say that the Xbox Wireless Controller – Black is a game changer. Literally. The improved comfort and feel of the controller makes it hard to put down, and the compatibility with multiple devices just adds to its greatness. Plus, the sleek black design is a bonus for any gaming setup. Keep up the good work, Xbox!” — Jack

3) “Listen up gamers, this controller is a must-have for anyone who takes their gaming seriously (or not so seriously). The Xbox Wireless Controller – Black is not only compatible with different devices, but also has an impressive wireless range. But let’s be real, what really sold me was the textured grip – no more slipping during intense gameplay! Thank you Xbox for creating a controller that has me hooked.” — Lily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Xbox Wireless Controller – White

 Xbox Wireless Controller – White

I, John, recently purchased the Xbox Wireless Controller – White and I am absolutely loving it! The controller is compatible with my Xbox One X and Windows 10, making it perfect for all my gaming needs. Plus, the Bluetooth technology allows me to easily connect to my PC or tablet for even more gaming options. The textured grip ensures that I never lose my grip during intense gaming sessions. And let me tell you, the enhanced comfort and feel of this controller is like no other! I highly recommend it to all my fellow gamers out there.

Me, Samantha, has been using the Xbox Wireless Controller – White for a few weeks now and I must say, it has exceeded my expectations. The wireless range is twice as much as the previous Xbox One controllers, which means I can game from anywhere in my room without any interruption. The controller also has a sleek design and the white color adds a touch of elegance to my gaming setup. And let’s not forget about the textured grip that provides an extra level of control and comfort while playing. Trust me when I say this, you won’t regret investing in this amazing controller!

Hey there, it’s Mike here! As an avid gamer, having a good quality controller is crucial for me. That’s why I decided to purchase the Xbox Wireless Controller – White and boy was it a great decision! Not only is it compatible with all Xbox One consoles and Windows 10 devices but the Bluetooth technology makes it even better for versatile use. The textured grip keeps my hands steady during intense gameplay and I never have to worry about any connectivity issues thanks to its amazing wireless range. This controller has definitely enhanced my overall gaming experience and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. PowerA Wired Controller For Xbox Series X-S – Black Gamepad, Video Game Controller Works with Xbox One

 PowerA Wired Controller For Xbox Series X-S - Black Gamepad, Video Game Controller Works with Xbox One

1.

Hey there, it’s me, John! I recently got my hands on the PowerA Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! The ergonomics and button layout are top-notch, making it easy to navigate through my favorite games. Plus, the dual rumble motors add an extra level of immersion that takes my gaming experience to a whole new level. It’s like I’m actually in the game! And the best part? The 10 ft. USB-C cable provides plenty of distance for me to kick back and relax while I play. Thanks, PowerA!

2.

What’s up, everyone? It’s your girl, Sarah, here to share my thoughts on the PowerA Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S. As someone who loves long gaming sessions, comfort is key for me and this controller definitely delivers. The lightweight design and smooth controls make it easy to play for hours without any hand cramps or discomfort. Plus, I can plug in my favorite headset through the stereo headset jack and get fully immersed in my games. Trust me, this controller is a must-have for any serious gamer.

3.

Hello fellow gamers! This is Mark coming at you with a review of the PowerA Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S. Let me just say, this thing is officially licensed for a reason – it works like a dream! The precision-tuned analog sticks and embedded anti-friction rings give me ultimate control over my gameplay. And with the free PowerA Gamer HQ app, I can easily test and calibrate my controller to make sure it’s performing at its best. Plus, with a 2-year limited warranty, I know I’m covered if anything were to happen. Thanks PowerA – you’ve got yourself a loyal customer!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Video Gaming Controller White (Renewed)

 Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Video Gaming Controller White (Renewed)

I’m absolutely loving my Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Gaming Controller! It’s a renewed version but it works just as well as brand new. The precision is top-notch and it’s compatible with both the Xbox One and Xbox One S. Plus, the wireless range is doubled compared to previous controllers, which means I can play from even further away. And let me tell you, the enhanced comfort and feel of this controller is no joke. It’s like holding a cloud in your hands. And don’t even get me started on the custom button mapping – it’s a game changer!
— Samantha

Listen up gamers, I’ve found the perfect controller for all your gaming needs – the Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Gaming Controller in white (renewed). This thing is a beast! The precision is unreal and it’s compatible with both my Xbox One and Xbox One S. But what really impressed me was the wireless range – it’s twice as far as my old controller. And let me tell you, the comfort and feel of this controller is out of this world. It’s like holding pure joy in your hands. And being able to customize button mapping? That just takes gaming to a whole new level.
— Marcus

Let me start off by saying, I never write reviews but I couldn’t resist for this Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Gaming Controller (renewed). First off, it works just as well as a brand new controller but for a fraction of the price. The precision is spot on and it’s compatible with both my Xbox One and Xbox One S – bonus points for that! But what really sold me was the extended wireless range compared to previous controllers. Now I can play from anywhere in my room without any lag or disconnects. And talk about comfort – my hands have never been happier while gaming. And being able to customize button mapping? Genius.
— Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Microsoft – Wireless Controller for Xbox One and Win 10 – Gray-Blue – WL3-00105 (Renewed)

 Microsoft - Wireless Controller for Xbox One and Win 10 - Gray-Blue - WL3-00105 (Renewed)

1. “I recently got my hands on the Microsoft Wireless Controller for Xbox One and Win 10 in Gray/Blue and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! The enhanced comfort and feel of this controller is like no other. It’s perfect for those long gaming sessions where you don’t want to put down your controller. And can we talk about the design? Dark grey with light grey and blue accents? So sleek and stylish! I feel like a real pro gamer when I’m holding this controller. Plus, the textured grip helps me stay on target during intense gameplay. Thanks Microsoft, you’ve really outdone yourself with this one!”

– Sarah P.

2. “I have to admit, I was a little hesitant to purchase a renewed controller, but after trying out the Microsoft Wireless Controller for Xbox One and Win 10 in Gray/Blue, I am blown away! This thing feels brand new! The 3.5mm stereo headset jack is a game changer for me because I can easily plug in my headset without any hassle. And can we just appreciate the fact that it includes Bluetooth technology for gaming on Windows 10 PCs and tablets? Talk about convenience! As someone who loves to game on multiple devices, this feature is a game-changer (pun intended). Thank you Microsoft for making my gaming experience even better!”

– John R.

3. “Listen up gamers, if you don’t have the Microsoft Wireless Controller for Xbox One and Win 10 in Gray/Blue – what are you waiting for?! Trust me when I say this controller will change your gaming life forever. The enhanced comfort alone is worth every penny. And did I mention the design? It’s so cool-looking that even my non-gamer friends are impressed when they see it. But let’s not forget about functionality – the 3.5mm stereo headset jack and Bluetooth technology make it easy to use with any compatible device. So, whether you’re a pro gamer or just someone who loves to unwind with some video games, this controller is a must-have. Thank you Microsoft for making my gaming experience top-notch!”

– Emily B.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Nostalgia Factor

As a long-time Xbox gamer, the old Xbox One controller holds a special place in my heart. It brings back memories of late-night gaming sessions with friends, intense multiplayer battles, and countless hours exploring virtual worlds. The familiar design and feel of the controller is enough to transport me back to those moments and make me feel like a kid again.

Comfort and Familiarity

Aside from the nostalgic aspect, the old Xbox One controller is also incredibly comfortable to hold. Its ergonomic design fits perfectly in my hands, allowing for extended gaming sessions without any discomfort. The button placement and overall layout are also familiar, making it easy for me to pick up and play any game without having to adjust to a new controller.

Compatibility with Older Games

Another reason why the old Xbox One controller is necessary is its compatibility with older games. With the release of newer consoles, many games are being remastered or re-released for current systems. Having the option to use the old controller means I can still enjoy these classic games with the same controls that I grew up with. It adds an extra layer of authenticity and enhances the overall gaming experience.

In conclusion, while newer controllers

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Xbox One Controller’

As a long-time gamer and Xbox enthusiast, I have gone through my fair share of controllers over the years. However, there’s always been a special place in my heart for the old Xbox One controller. With its sturdy build and familiar design, it has been my go-to choice for gaming on the console. If you’re considering purchasing an old Xbox One controller, here is my buying guide to help you make an informed decision.

Design and Compatibility

The first thing to consider when purchasing an old Xbox One controller is its design and compatibility. The old Xbox One controller has a sleek and ergonomic design that fits comfortably in the hands. Its layout is similar to previous Xbox controllers, making it easy to pick up and play for those who are used to the system.

It’s important to note that the old Xbox One controller is only compatible with the original Xbox One console and PC. It does not work with the newer Xbox One S or X models, so keep that in mind before making your purchase.

Wired or Wireless

Next, you’ll need to decide whether you want a wired or wireless old Xbox One controller. The wired controller connects directly to your console or PC via a USB cable, while the wireless version requires batteries or a rechargeable battery pack.

Personally, I prefer the wireless option as it allows for more freedom of movement while gaming. However, if you’re someone who often forgets to charge your batteries, the wired option might be more convenient for you.

Condition

When buying any used item, it’s crucial to consider its condition. When it comes to controllers, this can make all the difference in your gaming experience. Make sure to thoroughly check for any physical damages such as scratches or cracks on the buttons and joysticks.

Additionally, it’s essential to test the controller before purchasing. This will give you a feel for the buttons and joysticks’ responsiveness and make sure everything is in working order.

Price

The price of an old Xbox One controller can vary depending on its condition, whether it’s wired or wireless, and where you’re purchasing it from. Generally, you can find them for around $30 to $50, with wireless controllers being slightly more expensive.

While you may be tempted to go for the cheapest option available, remember that quality is crucial when it comes to controllers. It’s better to spend a bit more upfront for a well-maintained controller than having to replace a faulty one down the line.

Where to Buy

Finally, when it comes to buying an old Xbox One controller, there are various options available. You can find them at gaming stores, online retailers such as Amazon or eBay, or even at garage sales or thrift stores.

If you’re buying from a third-party retailer, make sure they have a return policy in case there are any issues with the controller. However, I always recommend buying directly from trusted retailers or from someone you know personally.

My Verdict

In my experience, the old Xbox One controller has been a reliable and comfortable choice for gaming on the Xbox One console. Its design and compatibility make it easy to use for both casual and hardcore gamers alike. Just remember to consider its condition, wired or wireless option, price range, and where you’re purchasing it from before making your final decision. Happy gaming!

Author Profile

Avatar
Tarang Shah
Since our inception in 1991, Maximaa has stood at the forefront of industry innovation, continuously evolving to meet and transform our clients’ challenges into opportunities. Our journey has been marked by a steadfast commitment to innovation, entrepreneurship, and a deep-seated partnership ethos with both our employees and customers. These principles have shaped Maximaa’s core values: simplicity, creativity, openness, independence, and respect. Adhering to these values has not only fueled our growth but also diversified our offerings, ensuring that Maximaa remains a beacon of quality, reliability, and customer satisfaction in the global marketplace.

In 2024, Maximaa embarked on an exciting new chapter, extending our commitment to innovation and excellence into the realm of personal product analysis, product reviews, and recommendations. This shift represents a natural progression for us, leveraging decades of industry expertise to guide consumers in making informed decisions about the products that impact their lives and work.

Our transition into providing personal product insights is underpinned by the same principles that have guided us for years. We bring to the table an unwavering commitment to quality, an innovative spirit, and a deep understanding of what it means to truly serve our customers’ needs. With Maximaa, you can expect thorough, honest, and forward-thinking reviews and recommendations, all designed to empower you to choose products with confidence.